hmm.no edges in the markets

[Tonkadad]

Quote from marketsurfer:

Well stated, satchel. Now the real traders have step forward and the mystics and positive thinkers have been neutralized. surf

I might be off base on what you are saying.......

But in one post you ask:

"WILL ANYONE ALLOW ME TO OBSERVE PRICE ACTION TRADING FOR 5 DAYS IN A ROW,"

(Not sure why the caps? Yelling, pleading.....)

and then you respond with the above:

"the mystics and positive thinkers have been neutralized" (which I assume you are referring to PA traders) not to mention all of the other taunts and challenges in the past.

I guess this is all just soap opera theatrics on your part.

Would you be willing to answer one question?

Do you receive any compensation or benefit in regards to your association with this site? If so in what capacity?

For the record : I am not yet a consistently profitable trader.

 

[marketsurfer]

Sure, I'll be happy to answer your questions.


Lots of benefits--- primarily from those who "get it" and are successful

Zero compensation other than the knowledge I made someone think and perhaps helped in their quest to find the truth. That's not theater and is 100% real.

surf

 

[wrbtrader]

Quote from marketsurfer:

Sure, I'll be happy to answer your questions.


Lots of benefits--- primarily from those who "get it" and are successful

Zero compensation other than the knowledge I made someone think and perhaps helped in their quest to find the truth. That's not theater and is 100% real.

surf

You said earlier you wanted to observe someone for 5 consecutive trading days while they trade price action in the described way.

1) Please clarify...you talking about in person, chat room live calls, chat room whiteboard with audio, ET forum live call or what ?

Note: ET does not have a chat room but there are hundreds of free chat room sources out there and some currently being used by traders to post live calls for many months or years.

2) Also, you said "in the described way". You want the person to share with you the in-depth details of their trade method or you're only interested in just generalities of the price action being discussed to you ?

3) Does this person have to be an ET member you've been debating with or can it be someone from outside of the ET forum ?

The above was reposted because it went unanswered by you after you made the request for someone to allow you into their trading world. Hopefully someone will step up to the plate for you that's outside the usual suspects you've been debating with depending upon how you answer the above questions.

Quote from marketsurfer:

...WILL ANYONE ALLOW ME TO OBSERVE PRICE ACTION TRADING FOR 5 DAYS IN A ROW...

 

[marketsurfer]

No I don't need it described, I just would like to observe-- even on a simulator--- 5 days

Thanks. Surf

 

[wrbtrader]

Quote from marketsurfer:

No I don't need it described, I just would like to observe-- even on a simulator--- 5 days

Thanks. Surf

Ok, so the person isn't required to explain to you HOW and WHY such a trade was taken. You will take them via their word its was from price action they are looking at on their charts or in combo of price action with other trading tools for a complete trading plan.

Also, please answer 1) and 3)...thanks.

 

[gmst]

Quote from wrbtrader:

Ok, so the person isn't required to explain to you HOW and WHY such a trade was taken. You will take them via their word its was from price action they are looking at on their charts or in combo of price action with other trading tools for a complete trading plan.

Also, please answer 1) and 3)...thanks.

you are such a nice and accomplished guy. I don't understand why you engaging in such debate with a stubborn dude. Maybe looking for entertainment

 

[marketsurfer]

Quote from wrbtrader:

Ok, so the person isn't required to explain to you HOW and WHY such a trade was taken. You will take them via their word its was from price action they are looking at on their charts or in combo of price action with other trading tools for a complete trading plan.

Also, please answer 1) and 3)...thanks.

1.-- if it isn't in an unbiased third party combine, i would like to observe their chart and entry screen via go to meeting or another service.

2. It has to be a person who has made claims of success and present a persona of a mentor, not to mention who claim their success can be "taught" or "programed" automated.

surf

 

[NoDoji]

It's all about the S and the R

 

[Tonkadad]

Quote from marketsurfer:

1.-- if it isn't in an unbiased third party combine, i would like to observe their chart and entry screen via go to meeting or another service.

2. It has to be a person who has made claims of success and present a persona of a mentor, not to mention who claim their success can be "taught" or "programed" automated.

surf

Are there any other conditions that need to be met?

Since you are being so reasonable with your requests I don't think it would be out of line if you required 50% of the profits for the week.

 

[NoDoji]

Quote from cornix:

Just read NoD's long post with attention... I agree with Sellindexvol... you're giving away too much!

I remember so many traders posting along the lines of "I just trade support and resistance" and I had no idea what they meant by that.

Now that I know what is meant by that.