Here's real verifiable proof 90% lose

Quote from ashatet:

This is simple really. Simulate this in the house. Let there be the whole family take part in this, say about 10 people. They will all start with say 1000 dollars funny money. They will trade with each other which is nothing more than the zero sum game and each of the players will give 1 cent to a piggy bank for trading and financing costs. After a lot of these games, they would all have lost and the only one to win will be the piggy bank, which is a broker.

The best way to trade is with other people's money, if you win, go shake hands with the people who lend with you the money, have dinner with them and share the money with them. If you lose, its their money, apologize and find someone else with money to invest. Sadly, this is how most of the money is made in the trading world.


this is the reason the US will eventually have a stock transaction tax. it fits in nicely with the obama view that all private assets belongs to the government and its friends..
 
Quote from ashatet:

This is simple really. Simulate this in the house. Let there be the whole family take part in this, say about 10 people. They will all start with say 1000 dollars funny money. They will trade with each other which is nothing more than the zero sum game and each of the players will give 1 cent to a piggy bank for trading and financing costs. After a lot of these games, they would all have lost and the only one to win will be the piggy bank, which is a broker.

The best way to trade is with other people's money, if you win, go shake hands with the people who lend with you the money, have dinner with them and share the money with them. If you lose, its their money, apologize and find someone else with money to invest. Sadly, this is how most of the money is made in the trading world.

agree
 
Quote from dwl603:

I believe he is referring to Dan Gibby, whose numbers are as follows...
bringing over a decade of experience ...
Japanese candlestick chart patterns.... record of high academic achievement....
a CPA (non-practicing) and attorney...
1) So much for education being any sort of factor with regards to success in trading.
2) So much for those stupid candlesticks.
 
Quote from larrybf:

the info about Dan Gibbey is truly eye opening....and I have beem trading for quite some time

Yeah especially if you put the pieces together on the timeline, he left Pristine where he was the "lead moderator and trading instructor of their trading room," right around the time his trading record starts with Tuco, then six months later after rolling through 35k and failing as a trader he goes straight back to teaching. Absolutely unbelievable, it is no wonder so many people fail at trading.

What is also unbelievable is that there are people on this site chasing off good traders with insanely high, verifiable PNL who want to teach for free, while assholes like Dan Gibby who cant even turn a profit charge thousands and are a dime a dozen.
 
Just a comment that I've made a few times before (and, yes, I guess I'm bias, and I guess my comments can be discounted as marketing, etc., but I think valid nonetheless).

Traders do not "fail" per se' - those who attempt trading for a living do fail, and in pretty high numbers.... just as every other business venture fails to the same extent. Traders have to make money or they are simply not traders any longer, they are forced to back and look for jobs in whatever field they can find. Face it, 90% of all business ventures fail.

What I tell new people, is that good traders will have a lifelong career (and point to some of our long term people). There are fewer and fewer jobs (getting worse as we know), and, yes, going it on your own is risky. Risk with reward is fine, risk without reward is foolish, as we all know.

From my website;

Quoted from the WSJ: John Canale, a former Morgan Stanley broker, has been trying to give brokers an alternative. In recent months, he has brought several former brokers over to his proprietary trading business. "This is a recession-proof job compared to being a broker," says Mr. Canale, who executes his trades through Bright Trading LLC. "When you're a retail broker, you just have to sit and wait for a bull market." Becoming a trader has allowed him to be more "nimble," he says. (Excerpt WSJ)

"While Wall Street is laying off, Bright Trading remains strong. Traders, brokers, analysts transition to trading for their own profits. Exceptional business model thriving. Click here for full article.


The way I look at it, if you're wanting to go it on your own, and make it in the securities industry, you can attempt it with a small retail account, or go about with: Lower risk (your deposit), unlimited upside (not blue sky, not rose colored glasses, but you can make a lot of money), No franchise fee and, where else can you borrow a $million every day for nothing?

To each is own, I bring this up not for controversy, just for conversation.

All the best,

Don
 
Quote from dwl603:

I believe he is refferring to Dan Gibby....... -34389 in about 6 months.


Danny boy's resume looks impressive, though. I need to copy a few sentences and paste them into my own, like

"_____joined ____ as _______ in the summer of _____, bringing over a decade of experience in the active trading profession."
 
Well everyone now knows it’s difficult to make money in trading and only about 5%-10% actually make money at it.

From this 90% that don’t what is interesting and still do not know is the breakdown of:

1. How many traders actually made money trading (that is showed a profit) before any trading expenses were deducted and then expenses hit and turned them unprofitable

Vs

2. How many traders actually lost money just trading, then the fees hit them and made them even more unprofitable.
 
I agree. Jesse livermore blew up numerous accounts in his lifetime


Quote from ShawnS:

This list is actually encouraging to me that theres some making as much money as they are.

90% of people failing at something is true for pretty much anything thats worth doing. The one's that fail just aren't into it enough to stick it out for the long haul.

You can't fail at anything if you dont give up:D
 
Back
Top