Gators are lazy frickin' pigs. The reservoir next to me (Medard Park) has thousands of the damn things, including a couple of monsters that look like dinosaurs, and pretty much all they ever do is sun themselves and grunt from being overstuffed. Every one of them is bloated to the max... because they've filled up on my bass and catfish. Dammit. They wouldn't know what to do with an arm in the water if you hit them in the head with the soggy end.
Just for the record, fatal gator attacks in the entire US average well under one per year. That's about 25x less than dogs. Pretty much the last thing to worry about.
While I tend to agree with your assessment, people do need to realize that gators are apex predators and not something to take lightly. The tragedy at Disney illustrates that. And I know you're not kidding about a few of them that reach cartoonish size. I've been told the smaller ones are more dangerous because of their speed and aggressiveness.
But man, those claws are huge up close...)