Quote from fxpeculator:
McKinsey lead Enron into collapse. The CEO Jeff Jeffrey Schilling was from McKinsey and they brought an entire barrage of consultants over to Enron before taking it into the ground. The corrupt and misguided "Asset Light" strategy all started at McKinsey and was praised as genius in the consultant community, before Enron sunk of course.
Now, McKinseyites are not your average guys, resumes with 4.0 1550 SAT's attached for the most are getting thrown in the trash, 165 LSAT or 650 GMAT, , don't think about it. Also, if your applying, make sure your from the right school as I know of a college graduate with perfect grades 4.0 and and 1590 on the SAT who did not make the first round of interviews because he was from the "wrong school". You would have to come from one of their feeder schools. I would have to say to my knowledge, there is no entity in America that is more elitist than McKinsey, save Skull & Bones.
These people who make it into McKinsey don't only have top 1% of their class grades and test scores and are from the "right schools" they have outrageous resumes like building the biggest snowman on record, working for the Gore campaign, Rhodes scholarship, fighting in Desort Storm, working for the UN, doing charity work in Sudan, stuff like that.
McKinsey has "in the box brains" meaning your not going to find billionaire ideas there, these billion dollar ideas are for the college dropouts to develop. But within the conventional box of intelligence, it would be hard to find better brains than McKinsey. It is a great place to "be from" as it is the "Bentley" of Corporate America but not a great place to be at.
But why would a trader think about working at McKinsey where top partners only bring in a couple million annually while top traders and fund managers bring in hundreds of millions? (Soros, Simon, Kovner, Lampert, etc.)
If you want bank and you have brains, boldness/balls, are emotionally detached, and have creativity, the markets are the best place for this person, not sitting in an office for 80 hrs a week trying to convince some hack CEO what is the best plan for him and his company to make a killing.