Sorry, don't see what's wrong with Levine's PNL graph.
One curious thing I also notice is that Ackman did the trade with the two counterparties whose analysts had the two highest VRX price targets. Funny how that works, innit?
Nowhere in his description (of Ackman's projectile-diarrhea R/R synth short) does it mention that he has risk to the puts, other than stating that he's short puts. The graph is a joke. He also states that Nomura needed to buy stock, well no shit, they're sitting on short synthetic shares. No way that Nomura lost a dime.