Have you been trading profitably for more than a year?

Have you been trading profitably for more than a year?

  • YES

    Votes: 152 58.2%
  • NO

    Votes: 109 41.8%

  • Total voters
    261
  • Poll closed .
Quote from mrmarket3:

Where did you come up with the absolute value for my position?? Also if you compare my unrealized loss to my realized gains..what do you come up with?

I believe we have made headway--He has admitted unrealized losses. That's step one.
 
who cares who is lying and who is not. i hope we all make money some day and enjoy it to the max. ya gotta love the game,but u need to make money also.take a survey to see who needs some help and positive feedback. i'll tell u guys i've lost more money than i should have trading the last 5 yrs. last year i traded twice for 2 wks each time while not working, and although i lost a little i think i'm trading better. maybe one day i can be on the good side of one of these surveys.
 
What I will be requiring here is real time posting of future trades ie entries and exits. I would ask that we see the next 25 in a row be profitable after commissions and fees. Certainly, I would think that if there are 79 in a row now, that roughly one third of that would be an easy target to hit for our verification purposes. Until that time, I will be disregarding the claims that have been made here. (For one, if there are unrealized losses, how many of those are there and will they really be all in a row as well when liquidated). Friendly challenge here
 
They were historical though and not realtime. We'll need to see them posted here in realtime without reference to your website. I would imagine, and perhaps the moderator can confirm, that the reference to the website is objectionable and not within guidelines.
 
Quote from mrmarket3:

All of these trades have always been posted on my website...go look:

www.mrmarketishuge.com

From the chart posted here, one can accurately develop their own picture of MrMarket's trading. According to my excel spreadsheet (and again using 100 share size trades), Mr. market purchased $293,005 USD worth of equities (during his 78 consecutive winning trades). He sold these equities for $341,251 USD. The resulting profits from these trades totaled: $48,246 USD. He accrued these profits over the course of 4 years and one month of trading (01-08-2002 until present). All the while, he still carries an unrealized loss of $15,938 USD (I incorrectly added up the numbers in my post to this thread).

From the other thread:

Quote from Spydertrader:

From the chart posted here, you indicate numerous purchases which you have yet to close out. Assuming each purchase only indicates 100 shares, I calculate (using the 'PAID' column) purchase price for all shares at $50,792 USD. Using the 'NOW' column for current price (although in fairness, prices do change each day), I calculate the current value of these shares (again assuming you only purchased 100 share lots for each) at $34,854 USD. Since percentages earned often provides less than a complete picture of actual value, I'm curious to know, How has your overall value of the portfolio improved (considering you currently carry a $15,938 USD unrealized loss)? numbers corrected from earlier post

Again, I only used a 100 share size position for the above calculations.

Quote from Spydertrader:

Also, why all the chest thumping over trading such small size?

Interestingly, It appears Mr. Market trades fewer shares than pounds he claims to bench press.

- Spydertrader
 
Quote from Buy1Sell2:

rip, there are 46,000 members and very few post. That's a lot of washouts. Now while it's true that many of those may have washed out and are not voting in the poll, that is the only point I can concede here. However, I would contend that this poll is still way off in it's positive slant if for no other reason than it is human nature to stretch the truth when someone can't put you to the test. I have read many posts here as well and can determine that there is quite a bit of failure. On a side note , if you divide the number of positive answers here by the 46,000 number, it's a pretty low percentage. That last bit was tongue in cheek


For all of the new commers here to ET welcome.:)

The reason that many of us "Old Heads" have not posted is because we are busy with our investments etc. Many of us came here back in the day with our arrogance with boastings and laughing and name calling and flaming etc. etc. etc. Most of us have moved on to bigger and better things. Some are still here at ET lurking every so often.

Life events,

As for me I have been through a very tremendous trial. I lost my 3 yr old son who died while impatient at a local hospital. He went in for the flu and dehidration and underwent 24 hrs of I.V. therapy. He was fine and back to his usual self then all of a sudden 24hrs before he was to be discharged from the hospital he died suddenly without explanation and without warning. The Hospital has coverd up the incident and we are still fighting them on the missed diagnosis and the misplacement of his medical records.

All that to say it has been overwhelming for me and my family. I don't know how to put it but like this:

I have been out of the market since then and I have since redirected my life and trying to perservere through this providence. You can't trade under these circumstances. Yes I do miss the market but not as much as I miss my son.

I have since shut down my entire trading operation. I stopped circulating my newsletter, I went off of the Air so I'm no longer on the radio doing the market show. I no longer hold seminars. I no longer manage money for other people. I did not blow up. However, I was profitable up until the day my little boy died. I just can't get it together to get back into the market right now. I do watch the market and I have kept my system up to date. I have watched the markets move without me.

The good news is that my system is still working just as it always did. And NO it is NOT for sale.:D

Just like the old saying goes:

"If you have a good, or great or near perfect system....you don't sell it, instead you keep it to yourself".

PS I really do miss you guys especially the ones that I use to fight with.:) Anyway ET seems to have cleaned up alot and it was for the best.

Good luck to all




These were the good old days.


2 Bar Charlie Live Demo


Scalping 101

E.T. Track Record:
 
Quote from mrmarket3:

T-REX,

Nothing more I can say other than my thoughts are with you. You've been through more heartache than any one of us can ever comprehend.

Keep your strength and your faith and may God be with you.

Ernie


Thanks,

Glad to see that your still up and running. Congratulations on the website. I like it. Keep us the good work.
 
Back
Top