Quote from Maverick74:
Heech, I'm very familiar with these deals. I may know who you are talking to if they are based out of CT. For me the deciding factor would be the reputation of the group you are dealing with. The guys I know in CT that are doing this are managing several hundred million. What you want to ask them is how much money have they already placed with other managers with the same setup. That goes a long way. Also see if you can talk to them to get a reference.
Not sharing in the losses is pretty standard actually. It looks bad on paper but "if" you are dealing with a reputable group, they should be able to raise you 50 to 100 million in a few years getting a standard 2/20. That would be very hard to do on your own. Also, the deals I have seen like this don't require you to use all that leverage. So I would just scale down the strategy and aim for high single digits return with drawdowns under 5%.
Also, get a firm commitment from them that after the deal expires that they will commit a minimum amount of funds if certain returns are realized.
The only reason someone would take this deal is to tap into their network and resources. If you could raise 100 million on your own you would have done it already right? So this might be your best chance. It all comes down to their reputation man. If they are reputable guys and they have followed through on their word on past deals, then it's a great opportunity.
He's already got $5MM AUM and on paper there isn't much difference between $5MM and $20MM. Both are considered small funds. Likely scenario seems to be that he might get a conventional fund started 3 years down the road with a 2/20 and about $50MM. I'm assuming he is talking annual returns of about 25%, which would give him a take home of about 2.5MM in the future fund. With his current acct size, he'll already be making more on personal capital by then.
IMO, deals like these are for standout traders who are just very under-capitalized (AUM approx $200K) and need a kick start. A good trader with $5MM AUM hardly needs a kick start.
You all pretty much hit every point, from every angle, I can think of.