Quote from Ricter:
You have some kind of snapshot view of reality here, instead of a process view. If I told my friend last month he could still load his plate as he has always done, but now cut the carbs, and after a month he gained only 10, where he used to gain 15, then it is entirely plausible that cutting carbs did it. So, if he keeps cutting, next month it could be a gain of 5, then a "gain" of zero, and then in the month after those, a loss of weight. That's why I said the analogy was lacking, it didn't account for some variable that is important and perhaps even key to being able to call this a diet.
I think you are just playing with the words. waste of time imo but you look smart in the mirror.