Sid seems to be about 50/50, (just spit-balling numbers). I've seen the guy post uncannily accurate projections in markets (first one that comes to mind is the peak in equities a year ago in early November). He had a few good calls in crude and an excellent one in bonds...This year, from what I could see, he was early and probably wrong on the decline in equities (albeit he was about a week early on the cycle low date for equities)...in fact that was the worst decline going into the election (just one week of relentless selling)...
I think there is a good reason why so many gravitate towards equities..whether implied or not, bulls can basically get bailed out of bad trades by a larger unidirectional market...one off events like last Jan-Feb are an anomaly, and realistically, prices recover in short order (either a massive one week spike higher) or one day wonder rallies..OTOH, you go long crude or gold at the wrong prices and you may not get bailed out of that trade.