Anyone with an idea of how much gold is out there in governments and private hands? How much is pulled out of the ground annually? Has there ever been talk of a gold production peak, ie we are not finding any new and will run out of sources in X amount of years?
I ask as I had an arguement/discussion with an econ professor at a dinner I was at about why a gold standard based economy is any different than the current basis for value of a dollar now. Isn't gold value simply a psychological, feel good concept? And that in turn drives a perceived value, real or not. Couldn't gold be compared to tulip bulbs? I haven't heard that gold is in finite supply, just that there are groups that hoard tremendous supplies of it as a fall back for their own piece of mind. Why not diamonds instead of gold? Or water which to me is potentially an infinitely more valueable commodity, and if you don't believe so just do some reading and look at various countries, states, communities that are battling for fresh water supplies currently. We have a huge battle in the Great Lakes region going on currently.
In other words, isn't gold value based on perceived value of gold and supply just the same as the dollar is based on perceived value and supply. Or is it the idea of having a fall back an extra feel good for the masses whether it is any more real than the current system. I would think gold based is open to manipulation as much as the current.
Gotta run for now, I hope for some good input.
Thanks
I ask as I had an arguement/discussion with an econ professor at a dinner I was at about why a gold standard based economy is any different than the current basis for value of a dollar now. Isn't gold value simply a psychological, feel good concept? And that in turn drives a perceived value, real or not. Couldn't gold be compared to tulip bulbs? I haven't heard that gold is in finite supply, just that there are groups that hoard tremendous supplies of it as a fall back for their own piece of mind. Why not diamonds instead of gold? Or water which to me is potentially an infinitely more valueable commodity, and if you don't believe so just do some reading and look at various countries, states, communities that are battling for fresh water supplies currently. We have a huge battle in the Great Lakes region going on currently.
In other words, isn't gold value based on perceived value of gold and supply just the same as the dollar is based on perceived value and supply. Or is it the idea of having a fall back an extra feel good for the masses whether it is any more real than the current system. I would think gold based is open to manipulation as much as the current.
Gotta run for now, I hope for some good input.
Thanks