jeeezus...
with all this deliberation over the efficacy of one solitary IBM trade you'd think the fate of the world rested on the outcome...
the point isn't whether or not the ibm trade is a good one (i'm sure all the gurus bashing it have taken the opposite side - yeah right!)... the point is that it was just an ad hoc "hmm, this looks good" spur of the moment thing... like a maiden waltzing through the countryside, stopping to smell whatever flower tickles her fancy...
which, in my not so humble opinion, is no way to make it in this biz...
if you wanna play at being george soros or jim rogers, .. ok, great... then it's time to hit the books and get a solid economic grounding... then your reasons are real reasons, not psychological rationalisations..
and yes, you are right, there are almost countless ways to make it with options... do you REALLY think you know what you're doing with them? seriously? bro, i bet you haven't got the slightest... when you can understand and explain everything in a book like McMillan, and have the know how to execute the trades, you can probably start to formulate some strategies... until then, it's just guesswork and luck...