FXCM Launches Net Stop and Limit Orders on U.S. Accounts

Quote from Jason Rogers:

The improvement is being able to set the stop/limit order through the Summary window rather than having to create OCO entry orders, and/or update the OCO entry order amount every time your net position size changes.

Wouldn't it have been easier to just have a stop/limit on each position?



akhhzk.jpg
 
Quote from cabletrader:

An improvement on none at all, but it looks like it's still too inflexible, for example.....

Trade 1 - Long 10k
Trade 2 - Long 20k
Trade 3 - Long 40k

On your platform I have to close Trade 1 first, then 2, then 3.

On other NFA-regulated broker's platforms I can close out trades in any order I like.


Quote from cabletrader:

Wouldn't it have been easier to just have a stop/limit on each position?



akhhzk.jpg

With the NFA FIFO rule you are not suppose to be able to attach a stop/limit on each position anymore. If you could then it would defeat the purpose of FIFO. The NFA wants the forex market to trade like the equity mkts, futures mkt, etc...

Now you can open an account with FXCM-UK and it would be business as usual.
 
Quote from operator:

With the NFA FIFO rule you are not suppose to be able to attach a stop/limit on each position anymore. If you could then it would defeat the purpose of FIFO. The NFA wants the forex market to trade like the equity mkts, futures mkt, etc...

Now you can open an account with FXCM-UK and it would be business as usual.

This is a subject which has been discussed at length around various forums.

The purpose of introducing FIFO was to stop brokers from taking advantage of customers naïvity. Up until then some brokers had allowed (even encouraged!) customers to have long and short positions open on the same pair, incorrectly referred to as 'hedging'.

Different brokers interpreted Rule 2-43(b) in different ways, one or two even went as far as saying the NFA had banned stop loss orders!!

For other brokers who had always offset positions using FIFO nothing changed, Stop Loss and Take Profit orders can still be applied to individual trades as usual.

But as always 'where there's a will there's a way'! If punters are insistent on being stupid there will always be someone willing to take advantage by offering them enough rope. :)
 
Quote from davidmaria1:

Funny. Oanda never even mentioned any rule changes.
Good thing, fifo would mess up my "double-down" strategy!:eek:

Hey, are you martingaling again!

Oanda have always operated FIFO, trades are offset against existing positions on the same pair.

If you've got 100k long Eur/Usd and you Sell 20k you'll be long 80k, you've never been able to be long 100k and short 20k on the same pair, at the same time, on the same account.

Go rake some leaves.....and stop smoking your home-grown!
smoking-red-eyes-009.gif
 
Ahhhhhhh.....blissful ignorance fits me well.
Got some raking planned today. I'll snap some pics.
I prefer to call it, "adding at support"
Had 3 long, closed 2, I'll close the 3rd if it breaks too far south.


jt19ur.jpg
 
Quote from cabletrader:

lol, we were both trading Eur/Aud last year, it's Aud/Usd this year!
I still think it's a great pair, for someone else to trade.
I think increasenow dipped his pen in it recently.
 
Quote from davidmaria1:

Ahhhhhhh.....blissful ignorance fits me well.
Got some raking planned today. I'll snap some pics.
I prefer to call it, "adding at support"
Had 3 long, closed 2, I'll close the 3rd if it breaks too far south.


Closed last long at .9333, just below s/rline, EUR/USD has resistance at approx 1.4950, may be early but may not.
 
Back
Top