Quote from bone:
From my experience as a commercial energy trader, the biggest hurdle in the past at least was or is the accounting means testing for FASB 133 compliance. In the past, the CL contract did not have a high enough positive correlation to Jet Fuel for an Airline to use it as a JP A or A-1 or JP B hedge. They frequently used Heating Oil or the ICE Gas/Oil contract or went OTC.
BTW, if you use a good broker like Amerex or ICAP Chapel Hill or TFS you can get a few thousand CL options ( and at a better bid / ask spread than the Nymex floor for a 50 lot ATM ) if you use the ICE Swaps or Nymex ClearPort for financial clearing.
Quote from bone:
For many commercial companies, the hedging person or group typically falls into the org chart for the CFO - which means they are stuck with the bean counters. And there has been much industry blow-back with how impractical and unworkable and untenable FASB 133 truly is or was. Revisions have been proposed in working groups.
Quote from OddTrader:
There are several major factors that have caused me to cease this fuel hedging experiment.
Quote from OddTrader:
imo, this call options hedging is basically a long hedge. I think it can be used mainly for hedging Short term demand in order to meet any sudden increase of sales that exceeds previously planned (i.e. already properly hedged) level of hedge. Therefore it has only very limited use. And very expensive.
Quote from atticus:
Ya, as a call is a hedge for any business with risk in a given commodity. Like Cargill hedging with Corn calls. Thanks so much, Captain Obvious.
Quote from ogarbitrage:
---------------------------------------------------------------
Quote from atticus:
I am confused. Is this clown a truck driver? Owns a railroad? Logistics Co.? What exactly is he hedging?
------------------------------------------------------------------
I tried to bring up this point pages ago. OP never answered.
Quote from bwolinsky:
If the intent was to hedge Fuel, I certainly don't get why RBOB GAS wasn't the first choice. Maybe liquidity, but there's no liquidity in CL options so that issue's moot.
This thread is littered with plagiarism, and the OP appears to have given up this thread after several losses.