chubbly, it looks as though you're making this personal. This started as a simple discussion concerning what may or may not be possible trading a highly leveraged futures instrument with a relatively small (to the amount of product controlled) capital. You're a smart guy, and, in my opinion, so is visaria. I'm sure I'm not alone in thinking this is (or, in some form,
could be) an interesting discussion, but it become productive only if we stick to the topic and not resort to personal attacks to make points.
I'd love to try something like this in a journal here at ET, because I happen to believe you could start with just a small amount and do wildly well. I don't do it for two reasons: I think announcing my trades publically might affect how I manage them, i.e. I might be tempted to stray significantly from doing what it is in best interest to do for the sake of public appearances; and 2) this thread itself is a perfect example of what one can expect from the audience.
Anyhow, this topic interests me, and I'd really enjoy someone making a sustained attempt starting with a small capital (and why so generous as $5K? How 'bout trying it with just a grand or two?) to do it in a journal and commit to maintaining the project for a pre-determined set time period. Or bust