How many of those parents, may I ask, had experienced the U.S. public schools so they had some basis for comparison?I have never heard any parent in France who sends their kid to public school say "Every kid should be so lucky as to get to go to school in France!" BTW - I worked in France in the early 90s.
I have met parents (mainly expatriates) who are very happy with the private schools their children went to in France (e.g. the "American school of Paris") -- but these schools are a very different experience than the French public schools.
My impression is that French public schools experience less variability in funding than U.S. schools, which unfortunately vary widely in that aspect from State to State and community to community. There is one France, including the French territories around the world, which are also part of France. Whereas, effectively, fifty bitchy countries make up the U.S. and share a few laws, but not all. U.S. Territories are not part of the U.S. but foreign lands over which the U.S. dictates and exercises veto power .
There is one notable feature of comparison between France and the U.S. , however, where there can be no argument. French wine, in France, is the better buy, by far!, than American wine in the U.S. If we can't have decent public schools, let us at least have decent wine at a fair price. If I decide to throw my hat in the ring for President this go round, that shall be my rallying cry.