When are you going to link us to your paid site ?
All these trade posting, and often late posts at that.......how does that help a newbie without giving your reasons behind the trade ?
I don't think these posts are designed to
"help a newbie" because a newbie should
not be following trade advice online by an anonymous poster nor by anyone that's not verifying they have skin in the game too. That's the reason why there's no timestamp for the trade entry / exit for you to compare to the timestamp of the message post...to make it difficult .
As for the
reasons that you've asked about...its obvious...this individual sometimes uses the word "we" in the other thread called
Long-term and Short-term Setups exclusively
technical analysis. You should then assume that the signal calls in this thread as via the same technical analysis that's discussed in the Long-term and Short-term Setups thread.
Simply, there's a relationship with the two different threads. The TA discussed in the charts of the other thread...should correlate with the signal calls in this thread that has no technical analysis discussions.
- If there's no relationship / no correlation...why would someone post education TA charts in one thread and then post signal calls in another thread via a completely different TA ?
In addition, if you doubt the technical analysis
or suspect the poster is not using the technical analysis correctly, you can always spend a weekend to backtest it on the Forex currency pairs discussed in this thread and then
reveal your own results to see how it correlates with the signal calls.
Most are not willing to spend a few hours on the weekend to backtest the TA discussed in the other thread and the thread starter is
not posting charts in this thread that goes with the signal calls.
- The real question...why are there no follow up charts, no chart timeframe used and no timestamps for the signal calls in this thread ?

wrbtrader