Fraud: Broker kind of "frontruns" client order. Reporting to SEC?

This is IMO even a VERY BIG FRAUD SCHEME!
It works as follows:
Broker replaces Client's order with its own order whereby changing the Bid to $0.30 from $0.35 (the original order never gets to the exchange!). If that new order then gets filled in the market, the broker "sells" it to the Client and makes a profit of the difference, ie. $0.05 !
The broker can never lose, it's a guaranteed profit for him, even more: when also the commission paid is considered... Client pays the commission AS WELL this kind of slippage fraud.
Gangsters!
I just wonder why none of these sleeping market watchdogs themselves catches such obvious fraud crimes committed by one of the biggest brokers in the industry...

Black scholes formula allows for this blatant fraud to happen. Trump was going to solve it in his second term but that’s why citadel and the big brokers helped the democrats cheat in the election.
 
...the monkeys when they blindly mash buttons on the colorful platforms of their PfoF brokers.

Get direct access, learn routing, problem solved

he should get his own broker dealer license. That’s the only way to trade and not get ripped off from this blatant fraud.
 
traider, I've monitored this happening daily for more than a week now, and have even made many screenshots, even of how other sites report the Bid of this option, and today I've even opened a support ticket and asked them about what's going on with my order. I'll summarize when I get a reply from them, but I think they will respond not before Monday.

I can't disclose the ticker here yet, but suffice to say that it's a "normal" listed option of a listed stock (ie. not OTC nor ADR or so) with spot < $1 (it's by definition NOT a penny stock! :) S.b. since it's a listed stock...) with low vol & low avgvol. I think the market of the stock is NasdaqCM. IV of the OTM strike used in the order is about 130%, it's a biotech stock (they often have such high IVs). And: it's a GTC limit order and I haven't changed the Bid since I initially submitted it.

The following info has IMO nothing to do with the subject here, I included it just for "completeness":
Regarding definition of "Penny Stock" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_stock )
Regulation
In the United States, regulators have defined a penny stock as a security that meets a number of specific standards. The criteria include price, market capitalization, and minimum shareholder equity.
Securities traded on a national stock exchange, regardless of price, are exempt from regulatory designation as a penny stock,[28] since it is thought that exchange-traded securities are less vulnerable to manipulation.[29] Therefore, Citigroup (NYSE:C) and other NYSE-listed securities which traded below $1.00 during the market downturn of 2008–09, while properly regarded as "low-priced" securities, were not technically "penny stocks".

Although penny stock trading in the United States is now primarily controlled through rules and regulations enforced by the SEC and FINRA, the genesis of this control is found in State securities law. The State of Georgia was the first state to codify a comprehensive penny stock securities law.[30] ...
 
Last edited:
16 exchanges tied together by linkage and one source of quotes - OPRA - changing the market on one exchange may or may not change the NBBO if it is multiply listed. The order would also need to be labeled "Firm" in the OPRA character field. If a better market existed away it should ship, unless labeled as not to. So kinda tough to accomplish this - would a broker really risk thousands in fines for $.05 and the likelihood of getting booted of OPRA and other sanctions.
Plus if this bullshit was true - wouldn't you want a higher bid - not a higher offer, but a higher bid as outlined.
You can send a tip to the SEC tipline if you thought this was systemic. Great Whistleblower rewards if fines are levied.
 
Last edited:
@ajacobson, thx, but what's the difference btw. bid and offer in your above sentence? I assume by offer you mean the ask price. But I haven't mentioned that side at all. So am a little bit confused of your formulation.
 
Just a blatant statement with no screenshot or anyting is gonna be very difficult to get anyone on your side since 98% of the time it is oversight by the client.
You can be assured that there is no oversight as I watched & monitored this happening for more than a week now since the beginning.
And others had such an experience as well, they confirmed my finding generally.

And: I suspect this fraud method is the method that allows most of the brokers recently (since RobinHood) to offer $0 commission :) What a gigantic FRAUD!
 
You can be assured that there is no oversight as I watched & monitored this happening for more than a week now since the beginning.
And others had such an experience as well, they confirmed my finding generally.
At least tell us which broker then.
 
Back
Top