So you found this thread to be compelling and indicative?I didn't even know Nitro was posting in P&R. Most of the stuff I'm referring to was in his black thread or everyday is black, whatever it was called. He had two very long running threads that go back years where he posted daily. His posts were becoming more and more over the top everyday. I do disagree with you that the trading threads are repetitive. There are some good threads with excellent posts but you have to pick your spots. To me P&R is repetitive and has been for over a decade. I haven't been down there in years. So no, I have not read any of scatty's recent posts. As far as Nitro goes, I recognize the pattern. It's subtle and it happens slowly over time, but I do see it.
https://www.elitetrader.com/et/threads/black-every-day.121509/
Any particular post or section that you found to be over the top and unreasonable? I don't recall ever visiting this thread before, but a quick look does not suggest over-the-top thinking. Pessimism, perhaps, but where does it cross the line to which you are alluding?