Ordinarily, the business judgment rule would apply. In this case it is my opinion, though it is to be decided, a higher standard may apply--something like the Unocal Enhanced Scrutiny Test, but different.
In the FON/PCS recombination, the Articles of Incorporation specifically require the deal be fair to BOTH shareholders. Consequently, a plaintiff's claim that the AWE deal has changed the valuation landscape becomes, in my opinion , irrelevant. PCS shareholders are not entitled to an acquisition premium.
I can't see the cases succeeding on the merits.
In the FON/PCS recombination, the Articles of Incorporation specifically require the deal be fair to BOTH shareholders. Consequently, a plaintiff's claim that the AWE deal has changed the valuation landscape becomes, in my opinion , irrelevant. PCS shareholders are not entitled to an acquisition premium.
I can't see the cases succeeding on the merits.