Fib levels: who uses them?

Do Fib #s hold any water?

  • Yes, but I have no idea why.

    Votes: 4 15.4%
  • Yes, they reflect natural wave tendencies.

    Votes: 5 19.2%
  • Yes, they work because other traders use them.

    Votes: 8 30.8%
  • No, they only work at random times.

    Votes: 2 7.7%
  • Maverick74 destroyed my family.

    Votes: 7 26.9%

  • Total voters
    26
Quote from Dogballoon:

I have <i>absolutely</i> no desire to get into a pissing contest. Furthermore, I believe it when some traders say they find a discretionary technique that works for them that doesn't require fundamental validation, as long as it is directly reflected in their P&L. I couldn't ever codify or explain what I find valuable in my PV analysis, and I believe the best traders intuitively understand order flow rather than repeatedly trade specific patterns.

I am simply looking for that validation for those who believe they understand it through and through. I am sorry if my question seemed antagonistic.

Agreed. I apply the technique directly to price action that I identify as impulsive and corrective. In other words, I am buying/selling the corrective pullbacks. I do believe that price movement has a fractal nature. When trading the eminis intraday I sometimes wonder about the "fundamental" analysis. I trade price. I hate to say it, but Elliott wave applied in a practical way does work for me in the markets.
 
I use them as secondary confirmation... For example, if I have a pattern, I enter after a solid close thru the 68.2% level
 
theses are hard and trying indicators. at first I was just using them for 50% retracement levels. but then I dug deeper and read about them and asked anybody who knew about them. I found how to use the fib time,circle,extension, and retracement. these numbers work because they are just support and resistance areas. if you place them from the right points they work.
 
Learning about fib many years ago changed my thinking from 1.000 s/r-levels to ca. 0.786 and 1.272.
80% of traders look for horizontal support(1.000).
 
Back
Top