Quote from zorrotrader:
grob,
Nice attachment. That is a very nice afternoon for a beginner, even a beginner who is sharing the button pushing duties. I have annotated my 5min and 1min charts.
Great effort. If you use the trading description sheet, you can transfer the print to that as well but reviwing the chart is a clearer thing to do.
I have tried to correlate your button pushing with numerous ideas you have presented here and elsewhere the past 12 months and have come to a several conclusions. tell me if i'm off base. First, i can probably remove the stochastic indicators from my charts since stochastics as previously discussed doesn't appear to be part of the data gathering for any of these trades this afternoon. I'm guessing the same can be said for MACD but i'm less certain about removing that one.
We use them. When I am one-on-one we always keep them as part of the coarse data gathering. As you suspect, they corroborate (lend support to the context) everything that is a finer measure.
I'm trying to look for the P V relationship for these trades on both the 5min and 1min chart. A best educated guess is a number of these trades were based upon the FBO/FR sequence for entry or exit. I get this from looking at the 1min chart.
Try to stick with the five minute chart; it takes the gee whiz out of trading. Here is a small drill to do. Look at volume bar sequences for trends. During anytime of the day the market either favors longs or shorts. What the market is favoring, is appearent in that the bars increase in relative volume as that trend proceeds. conversely, the volume shuts down (decreases, relatively) when a trend appears aginst the market trend. Today (Wednesay) the the market favored short oriented trends. I will go to detail on this. You knew by end of bar 7 from two volume comparisons that we had a market oriented to short tends today. Four red bars (1thru4), followed by black bars 5 and 6. Volume increased then decreased. I put light weight straight lines along the tops of these two volume shifts. Proff poitive that trends will tend to be short on increasing volume for the am and probably until something comes into the picture to change the market orientation. MACD and STCOs support this as well. All is well as a beginner looks for 600 bucks during the day. This thread is a 6000 dollar per month thread so it is not necessary to be more than a part time beginner in New Jersey.
A better guess is based upon all of your discussion of DOM and the Indu-YM spread that most/all of these trades were based upon those two indicators along with volume.
By using just the green above, you would do just fine. I build a person's manifestation of his potential by strengthening his beliefs in everyway I can. You demonstrate this acheivement by what you write. Thus we go from a coarse monitoring blunt success set of pictures to every finer pictures that allow: data gathering, analysis, decision making and action. All four parts all the time cycle after cycle.
The problem is when i annotate a spread chart your trades don't match my understanding of stretch-short and squeeze-long. Maybe that is a problem with reviewing charts after the fact. The only way to study DOM is in real time.
This is precisely true. Learning is a process and it can only be done in a dynamic setting. I am carrying out all the tasks necessary to get the books written on this. and naturally they will place the learner before a screen and he will do the process of participating with the market to begin to learn what the books ask of him.
Is your sequence for entry and i assume exit to gather and analyze in the following order volume -> spread -> DOM? With price confirming the three data points.
Yes. Precisely. You have assimilated from my posts the process of gathering data from coarse to meium to fine. You see to take into account ALL of these as a set to do analysis. You then see that your beliefs are held up to ompare the analysis to them. Monitoring is sensing and is half a pair; the other half is the emotion summoned. This emotion is present as you decide by testing against beliefs. I plant beliefs as pictures month after month year after year*. Your word "confirming" is an expression of data and beliefs matching and then causing you to act to continue to make money.
Lastly, your beginner must have experienced some fear and hope in several of these trades - maybe not as much as i might in a normal day since your beginner had some profits in the bank to work with. I'm interested in how you and your beginner dealt primarily with the pain of being down in a trade and the hope one feels when you are down and hoping for a wash. The fear of giving back profit seems less of an issue in this example since it appears that most exit decisions were made with excellent timing.
There are about 60 emotions to choose from. To summon. You will find that as you draw price trend channels that when you are in a channel the feeling you have as you do the DG, A ,D and A cycle that you "feel" as shown by emotions you summon that you are "on the right side of the trade" and you are "making money corresponding to the potential the market is presently giving you". You will listen to your body (breathing, heart rate, etc..) and know you are applying skills successfully.
whenever you are surprised by emotions that enter by their volition, you know that you have a situation to deal with personally that comes up under certain market conditions. See just below.
Is this done thru the 4-stepper or thru listing emotions that interfere and considering replacement emotions?
You are correct. We used steno pads for this and systemmatically repair the emotion that arrived of it's own accord and not by invitation. Everyone needs to deal with emotions. you continually deal with them as you monitor and debrief your existance. Not during trading though. You just note the situations a a journalling. And do the steno pad later. You will find that your complete set of emotions becomes alligned and any of them may be summoned. few, if any, will come to the suface unexpected.
anything you can do to move my understanding down the path would be appreciated.
Quote from zorrotrader:
grob,
Nice attachment. That is a very nice afternoon for a beginner, even a beginner who is sharing the button pushing duties. I have annotated my 5min and 1min charts.
Great effort. If you use the trading description sheet, you can transfer the print to that as well but reviwing the chart is a clearer thing to do.
I have tried to correlate your button pushing with numerous ideas you have presented here and elsewhere the past 12 months and have come to a several conclusions. tell me if i'm off base. First, i can probably remove the stochastic indicators from my charts since stochastics as previously discussed doesn't appear to be part of the data gathering for any of these trades this afternoon. I'm guessing the same can be said for MACD but i'm less certain about removing that one.
We use them. When I am one-on-one we always keep them as part of the coarse data gathering. As you suspect, they corroborate (lend support to the context) everything that is a finer measure.
I'm trying to look for the P V relationship for these trades on both the 5min and 1min chart. A best educated guess is a number of these trades were based upon the FBO/FR sequence for entry or exit. I get this from looking at the 1min chart.
Try to stick with the five minute chart; it takes the gee whiz out of trading. Here is a small drill to do. Look at volume bar sequences for trends. During anytime of the day the market either favors longs or shorts. What the market is favoring, is appearent in that the bars increase in relative volume as that trend proceeds. conversely, the volume shuts down (decreases, relatively) when a trend appears aginst the market trend. Today (Wednesay) the the market favored short oriented trends. I will go to detail on this. You knew by end of bar 7 from two volume comparisons that we had a market oriented to short tends today. Four red bars (1thru4), followed by black bars 5 and 6. Volume increased then decreased. I put light weight straight lines along the tops of these two volume shifts. Proff poitive that trends will tend to be short on increasing volume for the am and probably until something comes into the picture to change the market orientation. MACD and STCOs support this as well. All is well as a beginner looks for 600 bucks during the day. This thread is a 6000 dollar per month thread so it is not necessary to be more than a part time beginner in New Jersey.
A better guess is based upon all of your discussion of DOM and the Indu-YM spread that most/all of these trades were based upon those two indicators along with volume.
By using just the green above, you would do just fine. I build a person's manifestation of his potential by strengthening his beliefs in everyway I can. You demonstrate this acheivement by what you write. Thus we go from a coarse monitoring blunt success set of pictures to every finer pictures that allow: data gathering, analysis, decision making and action. All four parts all the time cycle after cycle.
The problem is when i annotate a spread chart your trades don't match my understanding of stretch-short and squeeze-long. Maybe that is a problem with reviewing charts after the fact. The only way to study DOM is in real time.
This is precisely true. Learning is a process and it can only be done in a dynamic setting. I am carrying out all the tasks necessary to get the books written on this. and naturally they will place the learner before a screen and he will do the process of participating with the market to begin to learn what the books ask of him.
Is your sequence for entry and i assume exit to gather and analyze in the following order volume -> spread -> DOM? With price confirming the three data points.
Yes. Precisely. You have assimilated from my posts the process of gathering data from coarse to meium to fine. You see to take into account ALL of these as a set to do analysis. You then see that your beliefs are held up to ompare the analysis to them. Monitoring is sensing and is half a pair; the other half is the emotion summoned. This emotion is present as you decide by testing against beliefs. I plant beliefs as pictures month after month year after year*. Your word "confirming" is an expression of data and beliefs matching and then causing you to act to continue to make money.
Lastly, your beginner must have experienced some fear and hope in several of these trades - maybe not as much as i might in a normal day since your beginner had some profits in the bank to work with. I'm interested in how you and your beginner dealt primarily with the pain of being down in a trade and the hope one feels when you are down and hoping for a wash. The fear of giving back profit seems less of an issue in this example since it appears that most exit decisions were made with excellent timing.
There are about 60 emotions to choose from. To summon. You will find that as you draw price trend channels that when you are in a channel the feeling you have as you do the DG, A ,D and A cycle that you "feel" as shown by emotions you summon that you are "on the right side of the trade" and you are "making money corresponding to the potential the market is presently giving you". You will listen to your body (breathing, heart rate, etc..) and know you are applying skills successfully.
whenever you are surprised by emotions that enter by their volition, you know that you have a situation to deal with personally that comes up under certain market conditions. See just below.
Is this done thru the 4-stepper or thru listing emotions that interfere and considering replacement emotions?
You are correct. We used steno pads for this and systemmatically repair the emotion that arrived of it's own accord and not by invitation. Everyone needs to deal with emotions. you continually deal with them as you monitor and debrief your existance. Not during trading though. You just note the situations a a journalling. And do the steno pad later. You will find that your complete set of emotions becomes alligned and any of them may be summoned. few, if any, will come to the suface unexpected.
anything you can do to move my understanding down the path would be appreciated.
Quote from jztrading:
I was wondering if anyone can shed light on the subject of fear in trading. I'veworked in the business for 15 years the last 87 as a marketmaker, I've done well, but like the rest of the trading world I was a victim of downsizing.I've been day/swing trading for the last 5 months and hav'nt made much. I beleive it is do to fear of failing or loosing too much money as I am the sole supporter of my wife and daughter and have high monthly bills about $6000. I know i can trade but cant get past that certain level and tart making money. has anyone ever been or is currently in this situation. Any feedback would be appreciated, thanks
Quote from Grob109:
Super post. I was hoping the thread originator would have a laugh in reflection. He certainly is gong to succeed and it is just a matter of getting on the right page,
What you are doing is right on and I will comment in color below to add a couple of notes to clarify..
What you have posted is extremely significant. you have engaged in a process for a year to iteratively refine how you do what you do. the most important thing you do in this post is to logically and completely post how you do what I have suggested. It is clear to every reader of your post by now, that you have really excelled in refining the opportunity that exists.
It is not just that by learning to do this you would have far exceeded 20 points/contract today; it is that you are well balnced, snsitive to furthering your performance and your well being.
Repeated failure is an unneccesary and irreversable process as we all see day by day at ET. Your post points out the available alternative as applied to any of the many successful trading methods.