Favorite momentum indicator? CCI vs Momentum opinions.

ET180 said:
I also have found no predictive value in any of the common technical indicators. This should not be a surprise. If there was predictive value, then everyone would be using it until the predictive value goes away. Although given that, interesting that you chose MACD as your name.
More...
%%
Exactly;
but some help a lot with probabilities..............................................................I neVer could find a use for MACD, but each to his own.:caution::caution:,:caution::caution::caution::caution::caution::caution::caution:
 
murray t turtle said:
or MACD
More...
does the op substitute the term 'Mom.' to stand in for MACD in the question - CCI or 'Mom.'?

"For the people who have used both CCI and Mom., which would you prefer? They are both momentum indicators and show roughly the same data, but are obviously different formulas. Any opinions matter, but if you have experience with both then let me know your thoughts.

(I know there are other momentum indicators, but for my own research and backtesting I would just like to know between these specific two, thanks!)

((If it matters to you, this is for Forex primarily))"
 
DisarM said:
both CCI and Mom.
More...


The Commodity Channel Index (CCI), the Momentum and the ATR Indicator.
https://www.colibritrader.com/three-less-known-trading-indicators-every-trader-know/

momentum indicator.png

.
 
easymon1 said:
does the op substitute the term 'Mom.' to stand in for MACD in the question - CCI or 'Mom.'?

"For the people who have used both CCI and Mom., which would you prefer? They are both momentum indicators and show roughly the same data, but are obviously different formulas. Any opinions matter, but if you have experience with both then let me know your thoughts.

(I know there are other momentum indicators, but for my own research and backtesting I would just like to know between these specific two, thanks!)

((If it matters to you, this is for Forex primarily))"
More...
%%
MACD, which includes a shorter moving average;
has a momo measure in that moving average[ema]. Don't know if any of that helps Forex.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top