You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
ES versus ER intraday- which is best to trade
- Thread starter hardyards
- Start date
ER2, smaller spread and lower commisions.
However if you trading more than 50 contracts at a time,
ES might be better.
However if you trading more than 50 contracts at a time,
ES might be better.
ER is thinner, more volatile and more jumpy. For same number of contracts, much riskier.
Quote from AAAintheBeltway:
ER is thinner, more volatile and more jumpy. For same number of contracts, much riskier.
If you want to compare apples to apples then you would have to use half the number of ES contracts to maintain the same approximate level of risk since one ES pt = $50, while an ER2 point = $100.
I've switched to the ER2 for the liquidity, volatility and what I see as more technically "cleaner" signals, ie less head-fakes. However, you would need to get used to the "jumpiness " as AAA alludes to. It can hop a point (10 ticks) in a second and can get crazily erratic in a fast market with prints going off seemingly all over the place. You can't tell this from a historical chart, of course.
--opm8
Right now, I prefer the ES. The erratic moves on the ER2 can take out stops rather quickly. Depending on how you trade, this may or may not be a problem. I like tight stops and to have a 10 second jump take your stop out only to go in the direction you expected is frustrating.
Quote from opm8:
If you want to compare apples to apples then you would have to use half the number of ES contracts to maintain the same approximate level of risk since one ES pt = $50, while an ER2 point = $100.
I've switched to the ER2 for the liquidity, volatility and what I see as more technically "cleaner" signals, ie less head-fakes. However, you would need to get used to the "jumpiness " as AAA alludes to. It can hop a point (10 ticks) in a second and can get crazily erratic in a fast market with prints going off seemingly all over the place. You can't tell this from a historical chart, of course.
--opm8
Yes and considering that the risk on ER2 is double that of the ES with the same number of contracts, you can save a lot of money on commisions by trading 5 contracts of ER2 instead of 10 contracts of ES for example.
As far as why its so jumpy I think its because it has a pretty big ATR of near 2% which is far larger than the ATRs for ES YM and NQ. And its has the smallest market cap of all four indexes.
Quote from brownsfan019:
Right now, I prefer the ES. The erratic moves on the ER2 can take out stops rather quickly. Depending on how you trade, this may or may not be a problem. I like tight stops and to have a 10 second jump take your stop out only to go in the direction you expected is frustrating. [/QUOTe
I agree if you are swing trading , or going for a longer time frame horizon ER2 might be a better deal ( save on the commish + more volatility)be sure to use a wide stop. But for tight indra day plays Es would be the way to go.
ES is choppy; ER2 tends to trend more smoothly, in general.
If you like buying dips and selling rallies on trendless days, then I'd suggest ES.
If you like buying/selling and, ideally, holding to the close on a trend day, then I'd go with ER2 or Nasdaq.
The ER2 reminds me of the Hang Seng Index (HSI), which trades overnight in Asia.
If you trade ER2 with tight stops, expect to get stopped out rather frequently.
JMHO.
Good luck.
If you like buying dips and selling rallies on trendless days, then I'd suggest ES.
If you like buying/selling and, ideally, holding to the close on a trend day, then I'd go with ER2 or Nasdaq.
The ER2 reminds me of the Hang Seng Index (HSI), which trades overnight in Asia.
If you trade ER2 with tight stops, expect to get stopped out rather frequently.
JMHO.
Good luck.