ES Journal Archive (2006 - 2008)
- Thread starter Buy1Sell2
- Start date
- Status
Nice blotter, but not even a line item from a fcm reflecting actual net p/l. I have never seen a fcm statement show anything but gross and net and never %return.
That was your ts excuse before. Ggoyal will be along any minute to defend you I am sure.
Good trading anek!
That was your ts excuse before. Ggoyal will be along any minute to defend you I am sure.
Good trading anek!
I'm not a vendor and I don't claim anything but you would think I'm entitled to some privacy in the manner I conduct my business when I'm just a retail trader.
Be thankful I took the time to reply considering I don't owe you or anyone for that matter, anything.
If you were smart you would take advantages of traders like me posting in ET but you are so brilliant you do the opposite, you waste our time.
Apologies to the OP.
Anek
PS: TS doesn't send statements until past midnight.
You claimed a $20,000+ day in a public forum. So what do you want, privacy or notoriety?
The reply is nothing to be thankful for as it did not address the issue.
If I were a smart individual, I would be looking for a poster who at least posted a line item from a fcm, showing net p/l regardless of their actual live calls or claims of overall profits and risks, or disclosed trades as hypothetical and taken with the benefit of hindsight or on a simulator.
Apologies to the op as well, but he does like to disregard trades and claims for the integrity the of thread and I hope he continues adhering to those standards. Just trying to help. Will gladly continue on another thread if any participant chooses to start before I do.
The reply is nothing to be thankful for as it did not address the issue.
If I were a smart individual, I would be looking for a poster who at least posted a line item from a fcm, showing net p/l regardless of their actual live calls or claims of overall profits and risks, or disclosed trades as hypothetical and taken with the benefit of hindsight or on a simulator.
Apologies to the op as well, but he does like to disregard trades and claims for the integrity the of thread and I hope he continues adhering to those standards. Just trying to help. Will gladly continue on another thread if any participant chooses to start before I do.
Your blotter did not directly state net p/l, nor did your chart. Many posters on the p/l thread have no problem making such attachment. And per b1, trades made in hindsight are disregarded for jounal integrity.
I might suggest to b1 that all trades on this thread should be regarded as hypothetical or simulated without a documented fcm net p/l line item posted, if his true interest is maintaining integrity.
I will not address this topic again and will ask b1 to define the terms for mantaining the integrity of this thread. I will be glad to continue this discussion in private or on another thread.
Good trading all...
I might suggest to b1 that all trades on this thread should be regarded as hypothetical or simulated without a documented fcm net p/l line item posted, if his true interest is maintaining integrity.
I will not address this topic again and will ask b1 to define the terms for mantaining the integrity of this thread. I will be glad to continue this discussion in private or on another thread.
Good trading all...
Sheesh I thought this was a thread to shoot the sh*t about the ES, not get into arguments over blotters...
Also, what is the point of publicly "disregarding" trades and what is the basis for doing so? For example, where the guy went long at 1193, by my chart he wasn't posting in hindsight, and anyway if I'm making hindsight calls the market won't go against me by 7 points...
Thank you for your time, back to the spooz.
Also, what is the point of publicly "disregarding" trades and what is the basis for doing so? For example, where the guy went long at 1193, by my chart he wasn't posting in hindsight, and anyway if I'm making hindsight calls the market won't go against me by 7 points...
Thank you for your time, back to the spooz.
startraitor, you've asked for p/l, then you are not satisfied with the answer and attack the person who posted it.
instead of focusing on somebody's p/l, focus on the trading. At least Anek has posted the chart of his entries/exits to show how he is trading. That was much more interesting to see (thank you Anek), then read your complains about his p/l.
How about you post your p/l or better yet post your trading chart, or anything educational for that matter instead of bashing other people.
- Status