Quote from smilingsynic:
Assuming that the loss is the same regardless of whether you hold for 2 or for 4, it makes much more sense to hold, at least if your figures are accurate.
Holding for 2 points=After 10 trades= 16 points (8 X2) profit - loss
Holding for 4 points=After 10 trades, 24 points (6 X 4) profit - loss.
Hey smilingsynic, I looked over your math and guess what?
You are correct.
Then I looked back over my charts and the percentages that I had listed in reference to my setups, and once again.
You are correct.
***
However, while we haven't really gone into it on this thread (but we did discuss it in detail on 4re's Support & Resistance thread), the
time factor involved in the 2pt trades is usually shorter than that required for the larger moves, and focusing on them will allow me to
make my money and take care of a lot of daily business that I'm responsible for. For example, after my first trade I:
1. Had a quick breakfast.
2. Did some banking.
3. Talked over the details with a friend who wants me to beta test a new software he's bringing to market.
4. Caught up with a former girlfriend (
wasn't my fault, she wanted someone who was more stable than a 40+ year old trader with a passion for the markets) who had emailed me to see how I was doing over the weekend.
I was also able to take another 2pt trade (which I saw move the full 6pts in the favor of my trade, BTW -
it was the afternoon sell-off but I was happy to hear the cash register ring
again on my 2pt trade), and
5. After my trade I left early and picked up some supplies from Duane Read before heading in to work.
So the point is, the short-term trades will also allow me to take care of a lot of other things besides
trading, so there are intangibles which I factor into my decisions besides pure points.
But thanks for your analysis, considering the win percentage, it will be easy to
scale-up as I start trading multiple contracts, and I could use a trade management algorithm such as
Apex82 uses if I want to
(sit in front of the screen all day) 
and hold for the bigger moves.
Good trading,
Jimmy Jam