What's burning on my mind is why he was such a staunch permabear all those years when the market was going up but decides to become a turncoat just before the market top. Seriously, am I the only one who's completely baffled?
I've known quite a few former "permabears" who were so burned in the aftermath of 2009, that they never shorted the market again. A weekly/monthly chart tells the story (until a month ago really).
This sort of permanent bullish bias makes one believe that no matter how much it sells off, no matter how much technical damage, it will ALWAYS be recovered.
I've pointed out the folly of this belief. First off, if/when the downside is reversed, vol. completely collapses. So, taking 100 pt ES stop outs several times per week CANNOT be recovered in a sub-20 VIX market. Yes, one could hold for weeks/months and recover some portion of the losses, but that's still a big "if". Secondly, taking a whole bunch of large stop outs will drive many traders to "tilt" since all of that buying/waiting/holding to get those points during the bull runs can be erased in an hour or two in this current market.
The "stairs up/elevator down" analogy just destroys people who refuse to step aside, change sides, etc.
On the other hand, maybe he got sick and tired of grinding out trades for years, posting his stuff and went Full Troll Mode. I can't figure the guy out, nor it seems can anyone else.