Since this is a thread about (day) trading ES i prefer to leave it here, however i am happy to discuss this subject further in another thread or private.
However i also prefer to get confronted by facts instead of just words without any backup, claiming that TA can predict what you are claiming is fine, but at least back it up with some examples.
I can link the majority of extraordinary/unexpected moves and long term changes in direction to some kind of fundamental factor and there are logical explanations for most other spikes (like algo's failing during a flash crash, fat finger mistakes, ...). I yet have to see an example of a major long term change in the markets based on TA without the move being caused by fundamentals.
I just find it very funy that a major move happens seconds after a news release, tweet, comment, ... and people then claim fundamentals had nothing to do with the move.