Wow, I'm not sure what to make of all this,.....
I do know for a fact, that in back testing, and back testing only, that wider stops produce far greater accuracy results than do tighter stops.
I personally know a trader, (ES only) who would use as much as a 6 point stop.
That always gave me sweaty palms just thinking about it.
His strategy was to look for trend days out of congestion / compression, so he only traded a few days a month at best.
I do find it interesting that people would post on a forum like this any system they are trying to "peddle" or otherwise have traders look at and comment on.
I would think starting your own blog would be a better format to do this,.....A few highly respected traders I know of started this way,....
As far as ET is concerned, I'm glad there are a few "real" traders here that actually share "true" market experience, and don't just spend their time demeaning others to make themselves feel better,.....
Case in point,...real traders have better things to do than rack up a few thousand posts over a short period of time.
I know I do,..and yes, I do this for a living, currently have a trading coach, and I am finally breaking out of "newbyville",...(thank God)
Again, thanks to all the traders here who have helped me in the past, and all the traders here who will help me in the future,....