Originally posted by Kymar
Just posted to the ET T-shirt thread, and, as I think about it, the contradiction I was looking at - "elite" vs. "largest community" - is obvious every time you log on, and look at the number of members - even forgetting that a few hundred of those are probably just FasterPussycat...
I had a negative impression of ET for a long time because I found the title dubious. When I first got into it, it was interesting for a while, but the disorganized, repetitious, and frequently mean-spirited quality of the whole thing has gotten on my nerves. I also despise the "don't share" attitude that has taken over: It's as though describing a trade set-up or rationale would somehow reveal a naive, unprofessional attitude. And if you happen to have a web site, have ever written a book or article, or have ever taught a class, or have any other side-interest connected to some actual trading expertise, get ready for a trashing...
I think the name actually has something to do with the problem: It's as though everyone who posts here and has any sense that he or she (both of you!) isn't really a member in good standing of any "elite" is driven to overcompensate by being obnoxious, as if taking a cheap shot at another contributor or broker or vendor or specialist or whoever, or being dismissive of others' ideas and secretive about one's own could confirm one's "elite" credentials.