I received and unsolicited invite from Dr. Steven Gundry in my email inbox yesterday, which prompted me to begin looking into the guy...
Lara Hyde, PhD. writes that in
The Plant Paradox, cardiologist Dr. Steven Gundry proposes that a lectin-free diet is the cure for nearly all health woes, which is what I think he probably talks about in this video (which I admittedly have not watched).
However, because this guy strikes me as being a bit of a crackpot (which is just my subjective impression and not an objective, fact-based opinion) I opted to watch this video about Gundry’s theory made by Hyde.
It's her opinion that there is a lack of research to substantiate the doctor's claims. But, here are critiques of her comments in the video:
- Gundry never said to not eat fruits or beans. There are over 15 fruits on his list that you can eat. And he said that beans can be eaten if cooked with a pressure cooker. And with tomatoes, you remove the skin and the seeds.
- Dr. Gundry does NOT eliminate legumes, etc. He eats them! He just wants people to be aware of preparing them correctly just like the ancient Okinawan people did to lower the lectins count. Proof is in the pudding. My health issues have disappeared since following Dr. Gundry’s advice.
- As a biologist it was interesting to me what he had to say and why. I got on his nutritional diet and not without difficulty. It has been about a month and it seems this new diet is a positive for me.
Given that I see no need for this diet for me personally, I plan to check into whether I can access Gundry’s book online at reduced cost (or no cost) just out of curiosity. In any case, Hyde responded to what I considered to be the best critique of her video (but was too long to include here) by writing the following:
Yes, I certainly agree with you that there is a need for more rigorous science in nutrition, especially in the area of autoimmune disease and diet from both the cause and management perspectives. If this diet works for managing your symptoms and your GI is on board then great, my issues are more pertaining to the diet being recommended as a cure-all for such a wide range of conditions outside of autoimmune diseases, such as obesity, cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes. There is such consistent evidence that diets high in fruits, vegetables, whole grains and legumes reduces risk of CVD and type 2 diabetes that I cringe when I see messaging that sways away from these knowns. It’s possible that avoidance of lectins or certain compounds in some lectin-containing foods are beneficial in the management of autoimmune diseases, but that is a much narrower application than is presented by Dr. Gundry. What I think we can both call for is more research - start with case studies of these personal stories in the medical literature and move forward to clinical trials to pinpoint whether avoidance of lectins/some other components of lectin-containing foods is effective in autoimmune management so that practitioners can make evidence based recommendations. Thanks for your comment! I read them all.
So then, this "controversy" seems to come down to how I feel about the attitude of a lot of so-called experts, including many traders here on ET, which is to say:
Don’t assume that what you do successfully will work for everyone and in every single circumstance, and don't assume that what doesn't work for you is not going to work for anyone or in any circumstance.
In the end, I think each individual needs to do his or her own research, and then do the best they can to make an objective decision about what will work best for them personally.