Here's my take on things. I grew up Catholic, and I believed what I was told about God and Jesus because I loved, respected, and trusted my parents, and mostly because Jesus' message just rang true. You can attack the churches, the religion, all the hypocrisy. It's tough to argue with a lot of that. I love science too, and I think evolution is correct and it's beautiful in it's own right. Because I believe in evolution on an intellectual level, it's very tough to swallow that anyone knows anything about God....what God wants...or anything about him....or It. What was 'God' doing all those years that man did not walk the earth? WTF? WTF are there so many other planets out there? Basically the Bible tells us that Man and his struggle against good and evil is the whole point of existence, but it just doesn't match up to what we see in the Universe. It simply doesn't make any sense. I do believe in 'something' that is like God but I also fully believe that no one has the first damn clue about the nature of that 'something' is like.
But getting back to Jesus, and why he's so popular and why people are willing to believe in these wild things like the resurrection....is because his message still rings true. His message was pretty simple: love everyone....love your enemy....forgive every time....don't judge others. Jesus hung out with the misfits and sinners for Christ's sake! (pun intended). Who has ever had a better message? If I'm going to latch on to anyone's teaching, it's going to be the guy with that message because...it just rings true. And also, what did those disciples die for if they did not believe? They continued to spread Jesus' teaching at the risk of their own lives, and some paid with their lives. Why would they do that if everything was made up?
I understand both sides of this argument, but I get turned off by anyone who says they 'know' the truth, and want to get on their megaphone and tell all the believers or non-believers how stupid they are. everyone has to come to their own conclusion and I can't judge or blame anyone for coming to the conclusion they come to.