So you wholeheartedly recommend Brook's teachings?
no not whole heartedly.
it took me 20 years and loss of over 200000 usd to get here.
trading 5 min is very challenging,
i am lucky i finally understood a few things.
i had 15 years of trading daily charts and futures and holding positions for 4 months. i had read my first technical book PRING in 1987.
even then it took me 20 years to survive in day trading and trading 5 min.
i misunderstood Brooks a lot in the beginning and i went in very confidently.
i would advice anyone starting Brooks to just stick strictly with his set ups and wait for them in trading,
patiently.
i have seen you may not get one workable set up sometimes for 3-4 hours.
and just stick to with trend trades or trades where the stop placement is available.
the main problem with 5 min is that if you cannot differentiate between trends and ranges then you are in for hell.
because most of Brooks set ups work when market is swinging cleanly.
other times they will fail miserably.
Unless you are willing to study him practice and not make money for 10 at least years do not practice his stuff.
i do not want to discourage you because he is good but he is also far from simple and his ideas cannot be taught on videos or books-face to face you will understand in no time
in any type of trading SEYKOTA'S advice is king:" if you cannot watch a profitable trader at work and learn the basics then restrict your trading to super market.
i should tell you in yesterday scalps i did not use set up based trading. if i had to wait for his setups i would not have made a single scalp. but i did use many of his concepts .and i understand high probability situations. that is key to scalping.
ultimately we have to develop your own style and in trading that is the biggest advantage that you can do it any way at all. There are no rules only guidelines.
keep an open mind do not spend too much on education try to learn everything
trading is one the toughest and most competitive business activities because the cost of entry is so low.