If you are a consistently disciplined risk management trader with a statistically viable trading edge then all you have to do is push another button (in addition to your main trading account) and make thousands extra every month for the cost of a few hundred bucks and a few seconds pushing the buy/sell button their trading platform.
Not a bad deal --- if you are good enough to pass their evaluation.
But let's be honest, most traders are not able to --
A trader who passes and consistently takes profit withdrawals from these Pay2Play firms WILL be able to make money afterwards for a long career
HOWEVER, IMHO 95% of the traders on elitetrader.com (who have never completed an evaluation at these P2P firms) will not be able to pass
Once you can squat 12 plates, squatting 4 plates is NOTHING!