I am active in the e-mini S&P (amongst others), and my portfolio Sharpe ratio over a statistically significant period of time is 3.96.
My strategy is based on an understanding of why markets move in the short term. In my opinion it is purely sentiment and market psychology. Markets are a forward looking discounting mechanism. If you listen to the market and can "get in the head" of what people are thinking and reacting to, you can get an edge.
I agree with you that short-term scalping is probably futile, the movements from minute to minute are probably a function of demand and supply which is inherently random. But my results from trading longer swings of 1-2 days is definitely not random.
My strategy is based on an understanding of why markets move in the short term. In my opinion it is purely sentiment and market psychology. Markets are a forward looking discounting mechanism. If you listen to the market and can "get in the head" of what people are thinking and reacting to, you can get an edge.
I agree with you that short-term scalping is probably futile, the movements from minute to minute are probably a function of demand and supply which is inherently random. But my results from trading longer swings of 1-2 days is definitely not random.
but also machines that trigger orders no matter what when some conditions are met like support and oversold condition or the reverse. Do you feel the same and how can so many fakeouts be explained?