i don't think so - Your not placing the upper TL on the highs throughout the entire pattern - that's putting your own spin on it. Both patterns are breaking rules of classical charting which voids this out. For example the larger pattern the second low is not lower - and it needs to be. The other problem on both of your patterns is that the reversals should not be more that 2 months apart or its no good. You smaller pattern on the right from April - June was a flat top broadening with a real nice break out in July - that did fit classical charting. Your trend lines cut through congestion at times - it has to link the reaction highs. I can guarantee you this is not a broadening top- not even remotely close.