Originally posted by alanm
I'd appreciate any discussion on how to read these. I try to (or am forced to) play these sometimes, and they seem to be really inconsistent. Sometimes, with a big sell imbalance for example, the first indication will appear to be too high, and then come down a couple times before it opens. Other times, the first indication is way too low, and comes up before it opens, which seems more intuitive if the purpose is to try to attract buyers.
Do different specialists use different tactics, or are they really getting such grossly conflicting information from the crowd? Sometimes, it seems that when he's almost ready to print an opening, someone shows up with another zillion shares to sell. Does this really happen?
When you say read these you aren't clear. Do you mean read specialist? Or Opening indications?
I'm assuming it is about Opening Indications?
First is there news?
How bad /good is the news?
Look at CRY and what happened last week
We couldn't get bullets after the market opened (but before the stock opened) as the bullet firm was out of inventory and needed to take some from the market........First time I couldn't get a bullet in my history with the firm. (after the open it was easy but we wanted that first print and shorts couldn't have it.
On days like those they aren't playing games. Usually when the volume surges like that they have to remove or take in inventory a lot more than the specialist would prefer. Orders are coming in left and right and they are just looking for some opposing orders.
A light is flashing at their post saying there is an order imbalance
they keep indicating lower until they can find some reasonable balance.
Sometimes they can't find a balance so they open up and than go in the same direction till they can find a balance. CRY is a great example. If you can get access to a one minute chart with volume you will see that once it started to go up right before there was a huge surge in volume.
On reading tapes and a specialist it is really simple. Well I'm going to give you the most simplistic form.
If I see lots of size going off on the ask (so that my time and sales are green) and there are big bidders well that means it is going up
If I see lots of size on the offer and prints hitting the bid --so that there is red on my time and sales well than the stock is going down.
Some specialist like to wiggle more than others. If you trade the same stock you will soon get a feel for how it trades after awhile. Keep yr size down as trying to learn.
Robert