It is the basic big choice for making money.
The choice that uses envelopes and periodicity
OR
The choice that uses the centered path of the market and its rubberband, the tendency to revert to the mean.
This forum is for:
"TA junkies, this is your forum for talking about technical indicators and chart patterns."
So what you are talking about may be misjudged as not being "technical indicators and chart patterns."
As usual it is best to be informed about both thoroughly. I always ask: "How does this help to make money?"
The path of the market is a fine thing to know about. But mostly it comes down to handling turning points of the market.
These turning points occur at extemes on the envelop it turns out. By focusing there at those extremes of price, is where the monitoring, analysis, decision making and timely action really pays off.
It like asking: "Do 'technical indicators and chart patterns.' help to make money. May be they do but not as well as envelopes and periodicity.
I am not welcome in the TA forum because I and others like me cause the moderator to raise the question "Where's the TA?".
It will be better if I don't post here anymore as a way of keeping the thread open for you.
I vote for the envelopes and periodicity stuff which is determined by the P, V relation. Math comes second; the market's ooperation comes first.
It is not a debate on right and wrong.