Does the world _have_ to be divided in a Covel v. Faith fashion (it seems that way from most comments directed at either of them) - Michael, obviously this is not directed at you as you have a "history" with Faith...
To be honest I have books from both and I enjoyed reading them both.
I ignore the debate that most seem to hang on to (and try to revive?)...
Even if Faith blew up his fund (these depositions are proof that this is fact), he is involved in the Trading Blox development which looks like a great trading system + the story he tells in his book is good (I dont care if its the absolute truth or not - you just have to take it for what it is: a story).
As for Covel, Trend Following is very good and inspiring (and endorsed by very succesful traders)... I believe if he was not selling systems but a very succesful fund manager (which he might be secretly?) his book would be hailed as the "greatest trading book of all time" - so its just a matter of context I believe: intrinsically the book is very good (what do you think there is to fault?).
Complete Turtle Trader was very good and insightful too.
Take them both as they are and I am sure you can benefit from both..