Quote from marketsurfer:
My primary motivation is to create conversation so that I can learn and obtain fodder for my writing. Sometimes you have to poke to get to the truth.
My point is retail dealer based FX is a rigged market, rigged against the small trader. all you need to do is read the literature of the company's that help set up the dealers to know this--- its not a secret---- Not to mention that 99% of chart based TA doesn't even make sense, let alone make profits. I am trying to discourage folks from going down the FX and TA road when there are regulated marketplaces and exchanges plus methods that can work trading other than the same old chart based TA. I am far from negative about trading---- just telling the truth I have found over the last 20 years actively involved. Peace-- surf
PS-- i must have missed your earlier post-- feel free to repost it or link me up.
Marketsurfer,
I appreciate you finally acknowledging my post
I believe there are many different ways to skin the cat in this game. It all comes down to whatever works for the individual, and what they are determined to make work. and all in all, its just a game of probabilities.
Technical patterns do appear, breakouts happen, consolidation, trends. some People CAN read charts, and base trades off them. I truly believe that. But then again, its up the the individual to determine which side of the bet to take.. and to define an edge, with a probability with money management, and all that kazaam...
Could you please explain to me why traders such as MARTY SCHWARTZ, DAN ZANGER, MARK. D COOK, ED SEKOYTA? (spelling) have done it successfully?
Here are a few members from FF that I know of, i don't frequent the forum much.. I also know there are many members from the james16 group that make a good living.
http://www.forexfactory.com/anup <- only uses TA, price action.
Another member I noticed awhile ago;
www.forexfactory.com/gregwilson
FX brokers, especially those regulated are pretty fair and stable. Regardless of being centralized, if you are are winner, its plain and simple.. you will make money. If you take loosing bets, its not the dealers fault..
And of course, I'm not talking about spread manipulation, stop hunting.. those types of brokers should be avoided from the start..
Cheers