Do Experienced Traders Still Paper Trade?

I agree with Mark Douglas on this. Simulated trading according to your plan / rules clearly shows you the mental gap - mental skills you need to acquire. It shows you what you could end up with and what you actually have trading live

The problem with this is the market can give you money this month simulated trading just because your system is tuned to current market conditions. Then you switch to live trading next month and do everything correctly and still lose money. So there are many variables.

For a scalper or daytrader you won't lose that much trading a month or a month and half by simulated trading. Still it does not have to prove the edge even if you end up with +++$$$. You could make money based on pure luck.

For a swing / long-term trader it makes no sense to paper trade I think ... Just keeping risk small and being very strict on money-management rules can give you enough time to reveal real potential of your trading system
 
Live trading 1 share of a $5 stock is more valuable than papertrading 1k shares of a $50 stock.

Like learning how to golf on a video game = papertrading vs learning on a real course = live trading.

Discipline, emotions, and risk management are only Really learned by trading live.


EXACTLY!! You are so right Ken. I have previously been an all-in believer in Paper Trading but I always lose in paper trading because there is no risk or live environment. When I experiment with daytrading 10 shares of AAPL in a PDT account I make money. When I daytrade MES live I make a small amount most days. If you can afford the 25K, zero stock commissions are real nice. AMP 84 cents RT on MES is a good 2nd choice.
 
Back
Top