I saw this on a DNDN message board.......let me know what you think about this posters logic:
I have been considering this question all weekend. Here's the question that arises for me.
If the Short interest wanted to make the most $$ possible on an approvable letter, if that is indeed what they expect to be the result of the fda's decision, why wouldn't they be driving the price up right now. If they have so much power over the pps then why not get approvable at $25 instead of $10. There is only so much downside in this stock. What keeps tickling my neck everytime I start to buy into this MASSIVE sales job that there is NO HOPE for outright approval based on all the efforts of the media, big money and anyone with a PHD who voted no for efficacy, the contrarian in me steps up.
IF the MMs really felt that Provenge would NOT get approval then right now I would expect them to be making $$ on the way up taking out retail short's stops and giving "sucker" longs false hope that somebody knows something and approval is emminent. Then, max pain/profit for them would have almost $22 within minutes of fda approvable letter on the downside. Instead, I have the gnawing feeling that while everyone is going insane beating DNDN down and selling left right and center because the risk SEEMS to get greater every day (in reality nothing has changed except the number of short shares) previously stalwart Longs are now coming up with new strategies to hedge their bets and lock in what is now looking like a decent profit sonce approval is getting to be a dimmer and dimmer light at the end of the tunnel.
I would argue that the reason there is no light left in the tunnel is because the big money is trying to cover every possible window so it APPEARS pitch black, we drop our shares, they go long and the sky is literally the limit. We all knew this would be the plan the day approval came from the panel. We all talked about how the next 6 weeks would be a vendetta to separate longs from their shares but we all felt secure that "THERE'S NO WAY THEIR GETTING MINE, APPROVAL IS IN THE BAG!" Look how effective they have been. I am still sitting still because the oldest tenent of successful trading keeps ringing in my ears, buy when everyone in the world is selling and sell when everyone is buying. Call me crazy.
This is the same thing that kept me in my seat through Panel decision without sweating as much as you might think. I just felt in the pit of my stomach that something was rotten in Denmark. Why SO much pressure down when the down side is where the money is made with a short position.