Epic Benchslap: University Of Florida Gets Spanked In Effort To Gag Professors Testifying Against State
Don't make US District Judge Mark Walker angry. You wouldn't like him when he's angry.
https://abovethelaw.com/2022/01/epi...t-to-gag-professors-testifying-against-state/
The University of Florida had to know it was going to lose this case. Barring professors from testifying as expert witnesses is a classic prior restraint, and doing it selectively based on whether they’re speaking against the state is unambiguously
not content neutral. But
the school probably didn’t expect to get compared to the Chinese Communist Party in the very first paragraph of the order granting the injunction.
So
it had to sting when US District Chief Judge Mark Walker began by invoking a statue commemorating the 1989 Tiananmen Square Massacre victims which was recently removed from the University of Hong Kong’s campus because administrators decided that disappearing a marker of Chinese government violence was in “the best interest of the University.” And in case the analogy wasn’t clear, the court described the ongoing decline of academic freedom in Hong Kong as university administrators buckle under China’s demands for “greater patriotism and national Chinese identity” in education.
In Florida, as in Hong Kong, academics are being censored at the behest of a capricious state which brooks no dissent. Election law scholars Daniel A. Smith, Michael McDonald, and Sharon Wright Austin were
blocked from testifying in a suit alleging that a recently enacted law deliberately disenfranchises minority voters because administrators determined that their testimony might “pose a conflict to the executive branch of the state of Florida create a conflict for the University of Florida.”
(More at above url)