I see two probable scenarios for oil now. First one is that we run to $150, top out, and fall back hard. Second is that it blows through $150, in which case I expect a giant parabolic blowoff top up to $190-200. I would then exit all longs into that runup and back up the truck on oil puts and place some outright shorts too. IMO if oil hits 190-200, it will then collapse back to at least 150 in short order (1-2 months), and probably back to 100 over the longer-term (say 9 months or so).
Thus I would recommend, once we get to say $147-148, exit longs and convert to calls instead to limit risk. Once we approach $150, it should either blow through or fall back pretty quick. I don't see it hitting $150 then sitting then for 1-2 months - it kinda has to make a move one way or the other. Thus options make the most sense.
Also you have a nice contingency trade. If it blows through $150, it isn't likely to stop at $160 or 165. No, the most likely scenario above $150 is a buying/short-covering panic, which IMO will take it all the way up to 190-200.
Thus, a great limited risk play would be to sell the $150 calls once we get to say $145-150, and buy more of the $170, 180, 190 and 200 calls. Basically do a ratio backspread. That way if 150 is resistance and oil falls back, you don't lose much. If oil blows up to 190-200 you make a killing. You lose if oil gradually creeps up to say 150-170, which IMO is unlikely without a final blowoff spurt up.
Any comments?