Quote from spindr0:
Yes, you have the profit numbers right IF SSO is at 43 or higher at expiration. The problem is that you're getting hung up on the brokerage statement.
Right now you have a $570 gain on the stock and a $70 loss on the option. You're ahead by $500.
If SSO is 43 at expiration, you will get another $75 from the stock since you have agreed to sell it at 43. The option will be worthless and that current $69 paper loss will turn into a $58 gain Add em up. $500 + $75 + $70 +$59 = $704 which is what you got.
The short answer today is:
Forget the -$69. You're $500 ahead.
The short answer if assigned is
1) $646 gain from the stock
2) $58 gain from the call
3) Maximum gain $704
If the option expires when the stock is at $42, he will show a loss on the option but still a gain on the stock (since his average cost was $36.54).
In that case, will the paper loss on the option disappear and be replaced with his $58 premium?
So if the stock is $42, his profit will be $546 for the stock (which he still owns because it was not called away), and then $58 for the premium (despite the paper loss on the option), for a total of $604. Is this right?
see ASE1245's post here:
So it sounds like it can technically happen if the option holder wants to do it, but it isn't very likely.
I was just curious if maybe some guy who is long some options gets all excited when they get ITM and wants to cash them out rather than possibly having them go back OTM before expiration.