It was just a statement based on logic. Try this after the fact test: find a stretch of prices when there is a run away run-up and see what buying calls will get you - big profit.My comment was in responce to Chef's "In a run away bull market, it is better to just buy calls"
From my limited testing with Orats,buying calls on the SPY was mediocre,and I was wondering if Chef had run a simulation that combined the results of 30 large cap stocks as you did or a mix of large cap/small cap
Of course you have to know when there is a "run away bull market", otherwise all the calls that ended up worthless will eat up all your profits. There is no free lunch in options.
It will take me months to calculate one stock and it is beyond my capability to run a combined 30 large cap stocks. You won't get any answer from me.