Cornix's TA Performance
- Thread starter cornix
- Start date
Hmmm,, everyone else does it in real time. You don't know the signals before they happen?
Assuming no chicenary, how does one know if its TA working, your psychic ability as a trader, skill having nothing to do with TA, or just a lucky streak if you dont post before the fact calls? Blotters will just show profit or loss---- I can guess and get both results-- will not "prove" TA. Only before the fact calls, that can be witnessed live is proof for TA. You claim to do this in a chat room, why not just post it here instead??
Remember, you don't have to post every call to prove TA-- maybe just post the longer term ones??
surf
Quote from cornix:
Blotter will include CTS T4 instrument symbol to make sure it's live trades. More serious due diligence is possible in future but certainly not going to throw pearls to the pigs, so only for serious people who are constructively interested in the matter.
What's CTS T4 instrument?
I don't know who does and what's their style. Also I don't want to post sporadic calls, want to show actual performance record of certain signals. Sometimes I know the entry and place an order minutes before entry and sometimes less than a second or real-time.
You certainly have a point that it's possibly not TA, but here's my statement: I don't use anything but chart reading, I trade on a regulated market so collusion with a broker is impossible. The choice is limited: either it is TA or psychic abilities. Proving whichever would be equally interesting.
As for the streak lucky or unlucky, I will provide enough sample size to make it significant proof and unlikely just a random streak.
Quote from toolazy:
Ok, looking forward
I will believe screenshot of trades with timestamps, If you have to, you can erase lots. But believe you trade around 10 lots or so.
Total PL figure only is not convincing.
I'll post blotters with P&L in points per contracts, because as I said it's the most objective measure of performance provided risk per trade in points is also known.
Dollar figure is none of anybody's business (I live in Russia, don't forget it
) and can greatly vary without slightest change in style depending if one trades 1 or 50 cars.No drama queen, just scientific skepticism about the methodology. Remember, this has been claimed, challenged and failed many times over the last decade.
I hope he can prove me wrong, as I would love to see it, but the rules of the game need to be set first otherwise nothing is proved but a winning streak or losing streak and thats if nothing has been altered. surf