Cornix's TA Performance

[Lord.Maushi]

Cornix has accomplished precisely what he wanted, to continue debating Surf after he was asked to leave his journal.

Well crafted.

 

[cornix]

Quote from Samsara:

Personally, kind of trading isn't much my thing and I also wouldn't be convinced without real time entry and exit as well. Although if I did still trade like this, I wouldn't waste time at the start and end of each trade posting the data on ET either.

But there are time stamps in that blotter, which is what he said in the post you're quoting. So unless the absence of size or real time entry and exit are deal-breakers for you, what he's posting seems to cross a minimum threshold of accountability.

If ET had a live chat like in good old days it could be closer to real-time. But chat ceased to exist.

 

[atticus]

Quote from Samsara:

Personally, kind of trading isn't much my thing and I also wouldn't be convinced without real time entry and exit as well. Although if I did still trade like this, I wouldn't waste time at the start and end of each trade posting the data on ET either.

But there are time stamps in that blotter, which is what he said in the post you're quoting. So unless the absence of size or real time entry and exit are deal-breakers for you, what he's posting seems to cross a minimum threshold of accountability.

30 posts by cornix on this thread... in one day, and no trade entries.

 

[marketsurfer]

Quote from Lord.Maushi:

Cornix has accomplished precisely what he wanted, to continue debating Surf after he was asked to leave his journal.

Well crafted.

I love a good debate, just not the same thing over and over again on my journal. I am 100% for cornix saying whatever he wants and claiming 20% returns are poor trading on his own journal----- just want to keep the nonsense off my journal.

surf

 

[cornix]

Quote from marketsurfer:

You mean by risking my own money with you? sure, that would be one way, but its much easier for both of us just to post the entry level in advance then the exit. Maybe, after I see this, I'll give you trading authorization over an account-- but so far, I have not seen any factual evidence of anything. surf

So far I better just keep doing things in a comfortable manner. Whoever believes or not is not so important, time will sort everything out.

 

[cornix]

Quote from marketsurfer:

I love a good debate, just not the same thing over and over again on my journal. I am 100% for cornix saying whatever he wants and claiming 20% returns are poor trading on his own journal----- just want to keep the nonsense off my journal.

surf

I still stand on that claim: 20% annually is poor result for a day trader.

 

[marketsurfer]

Quote from atticus:

30 posts by cornix on this thread... in one day, and no trade entries.

The entries and exits, although not daily, happen so fast--he can't post the entry before the fact. That's what he says.

surf

 

[marketsurfer]

Quote from cornix:

I still stand on that claim: 20% annually is poor result for a day trader.

Well, this journal is your chance to PROVE you are among the top 10 traders who have ever lived by proving that statement here.

surf

 

[cornix]

Quote from atticus:

30 posts by cornix on this thread... in one day, and no trade entries.

There was one trade, blotter was posted. It happened immediately after ISM report, sorry for trading then instead of posting here.

 

[R. Raskolnikov]

Not for any daytrader, but a good, experienced one should be able to do much better than 20%.

Quote from cornix:

I still stand on that claim: 20% annually is poor result for a day trader.