Cooltraderdude's TopstepTrader Combine (daily trade report and journal)

Quote from SteveNYC:

Mav should do the Combine. It will speak volumes re: Combine.

This is the most interesting post re: TST.

Mav, please do the Combine and show us how a professional trades and demonstrate the value of the Combine.

Oh hell yeah!!!!:p

Mav do the Combine with a live journal...!!!!!

Quote from SteveNYC:

Deal sux. Period.

Capital building is total bullshit.

Lame ass excuse is that the trader would be psychologically damaged if the trader goes back to the Combine.

Why would you send a profitable trader back to the Combine.

That's like benching Eli Manning b/c he threw 3 INTs that resulted in 3 touchdowns against the classless Buccaneers of Tampa Bay.

You keep Manning in there and let him do his thing.

End result: Manning throws over 500 yards and Giants win. Yeah!!!!!

You've made a really good point here... Reality... Manning throws 500 yards in simulator but sucks a little again when he goes live and gets sent back to simulator... Manning is toast!
 
Quote from CoolTraderDude:

Still trying to answer 2 questions...

1. Can I still scalp/trade short term...?

2. If I can't is it me or is it that the market no longer permits this...?

Quote from CoolTraderDude:

Quote from Laissez Faire:

I don`t know your background, but you don`t sound very smart.

Well I'm smarter than you...

:p
 
Quote from MichaelPatak:

.. cooltraderdue does not have to trade everyday. He can choose 10 trading days withing the next 30 calendar days.

mp
cough cough, another ET gem. Thanks MP! good trading is about waiting. alot of it.

and cooldude stay off that addictive dom? dom or charts not both. 3 charts with 3 timeframes. simple.
 
Quote from satchel:

cough cough, another ET gem. Thanks MP! good trading is about waiting. alot of it.

and cooldude stay off that addictive dom? dom or charts not both. 3 charts with 3 timeframes. simple.

agreed.. we have a lot of guys come into the Combine looking to trade many products and slapping on indicator after indicator....

We're on the trading floor and the traders in the pits that are on screens now, have their ladders(DOM) up only.. rarely do you walk by and see a guy with all charts. They get their levels in the morning when they get in and wait for the market to get to these and then see how it is setting up, firming up, or weakening up...

Keep it simple stupid is the motto...

mp
 
Quote from Laissez Faire:

Corrected.



Of course. Nothing wrong with these rules and the trader is free to disregard them after earning a cushion of $5000 dollars, right? Show that you can manage risk and after showing you can earn money, do as you please?

I honestly don`t see the problem or what people are bitching about. If people want to average down and lose, they can do it with their own money.

The reason you don`t agree with or fully understand rule number 3, is because ScalperJoe is quoting it WRONG.

It states that if you`re up $500 (or more) or $1000 (or more), depending on account size, you will STOP trading if your equity goes below the 50% high water mark.

Example: I`m up $700 dollars on the minimum account, but if I start piling up losers, I will quit trading if I go below $350. However, I can go from $700 down to $500 and then up to $1000, as an example.

It`s a defensive money management rule and I`m sure I`m not the only one who`s been up a great deal of money for the day only to waste it away and have a red day. I think the rule makes a lot of sense, but again, traders can disregard it after they`ve proven themselves, but most would probably be better off following it.

Hell, I should get a free combine for all the time I spent clearing up the rules for TST. You reading Michael?

Not my fault that people don`t know how to read or assimilate information.

:p

Actually, I quoted it directly from the trading plan. Your example is correct, if someone is UP $700, they should stop if they start losing $350, but nothing stops them from being up $700, losing $200 (thereby net up $500, so still below the 50% pullback), and then back up to $1,000.

Your post simply states the obvious. Of course these do not have to be followed once the cushion has been built, since the trader would then have 5k of their profits on the line.

There were posts stating that traders were "gunning it" into the close of the combine. My post simply clarified that trading in the combine allows for BROADER DISCRETION than trading in the live account (called the "live combine").
 
Quote from nazzdack:

1) 1, 2, 4 & 5 should already be incorporated into one's trading method. They shouldn't be thought of as additional guidelines. :cool:
2) I don't agree with 3. I'm not sure if I fully understand the first part of it. :confused:

1) Agreed, it's better to have it incorporated into one's trading plan than not. However, the fact still remains that these ARE additional metrics that traders must abide by in their live account, but NOT in the combine. Those doing the combine may simply want to read the .pdf so that there are no surprises once they get their live account.

2) See my reply to the op.
 
Quote from ScalperJoe:

1) Agreed, it's better to have it incorporated into one's trading plan than not. However, the fact still remains that these ARE additional metrics that traders must abide by in their live account, but NOT in the combine. Those doing the combine may simply want to read the .pdf so that there are no surprises once they get their live account.

2) See my reply to the op.

Actually Joe, Michael has stated many times you can revise even that trading plan agreement. Everything is negotiable in life. Never pay sticker price.
 
Well took many small losses on the uptick in S&P expecting the sell off...

Was profitable 1 trade in Euro...

Held the S&P sell off from the top trade... Net +$187.50
 

Attachments

Back
Top