Interesting comments on the outlook this week. Never seen the writers of this thing get that analytical...
---------------
"THE FINAL ARBITER
One certainty is the fact the futures prices posted at the close of any given day will not be the final prices realized at the termination of a specific monthly contract. They simply represent the consensus guess made by traders, with differing objectives and views of the final price. Each transaction posted on the exchange represents two opinions of the market direction – a long and a short. Some positions might be taking on price risk and some taking off price risk.
The current trading environment is dominated by the macro-traders betting on a recession and the attendant impact of declining commodity prices and rising un-employment. Many of these traders have never seen a steer and some are not aware of cattle herd liquidation cycles and our current position in that cycle. Their positions in cattle are often accompanied by associated shorts in the grains and metals. Their objective is a big picture bet, and the scope of the investment size is large.
This negative price environment has denied margin protection to many of the hedged feeding operations. Hedged cattle as a percentage of total numbers of cattle on feed is in decline. Many operators refuse to hedge a loss. This in time will change as equity losses force some unhedged cattle owners out of the market. So long as equity levels are high in the industry, people will overpay for feeder cattle.
The leadership of cash prices over futures is not limited to the live cattle contract. A mirror scenario is occurring in the feeder contract where feeder cattle prices are exceeding the spot feeder futures price/index. Feeder cattle that earlier this year were selling with deep discounts to a runaway futures market are now often premium. Ultimately, supply/demand rules and sellers with a product in scarce supply will be able to dictate the price of the physical commodity.
The open and free marketplace will always be the final Arbiter of price. The macro traders can make their bets on the impact of a recession and the speculative longs can take the opposite position calculating on a sharply reduced supply of beef, but no one can accurately forecast how all these factors will balance out until the fat lady sings."
-------------------
---------------
"THE FINAL ARBITER
One certainty is the fact the futures prices posted at the close of any given day will not be the final prices realized at the termination of a specific monthly contract. They simply represent the consensus guess made by traders, with differing objectives and views of the final price. Each transaction posted on the exchange represents two opinions of the market direction – a long and a short. Some positions might be taking on price risk and some taking off price risk.
The current trading environment is dominated by the macro-traders betting on a recession and the attendant impact of declining commodity prices and rising un-employment. Many of these traders have never seen a steer and some are not aware of cattle herd liquidation cycles and our current position in that cycle. Their positions in cattle are often accompanied by associated shorts in the grains and metals. Their objective is a big picture bet, and the scope of the investment size is large.
This negative price environment has denied margin protection to many of the hedged feeding operations. Hedged cattle as a percentage of total numbers of cattle on feed is in decline. Many operators refuse to hedge a loss. This in time will change as equity losses force some unhedged cattle owners out of the market. So long as equity levels are high in the industry, people will overpay for feeder cattle.
The leadership of cash prices over futures is not limited to the live cattle contract. A mirror scenario is occurring in the feeder contract where feeder cattle prices are exceeding the spot feeder futures price/index. Feeder cattle that earlier this year were selling with deep discounts to a runaway futures market are now often premium. Ultimately, supply/demand rules and sellers with a product in scarce supply will be able to dictate the price of the physical commodity.
The open and free marketplace will always be the final Arbiter of price. The macro traders can make their bets on the impact of a recession and the speculative longs can take the opposite position calculating on a sharply reduced supply of beef, but no one can accurately forecast how all these factors will balance out until the fat lady sings."
-------------------