I guess you could limit the futures market to only allow hedgers but who's going to absorb the risk on the other side? If you're hoping that the short hedger is always going to be there for the long hedger at the right price and time, and vice versa, good luck with that...
Not to mention the size of the global OTC energy market is infinitely larger than NYMEX and ICE...As a result increasing margins will only remove a small fraction of the specs, the large funds have the capital to trade OTC.
What's funny is that you'll rarely see anything like Calpers recent announcement that they are allocating billions of dollars to commodities in the news...The average American wouldn't be to happy to hear that "the retirement funds of California govt employees are driving up the price of crude"...
Not to mention the size of the global OTC energy market is infinitely larger than NYMEX and ICE...As a result increasing margins will only remove a small fraction of the specs, the large funds have the capital to trade OTC.
What's funny is that you'll rarely see anything like Calpers recent announcement that they are allocating billions of dollars to commodities in the news...The average American wouldn't be to happy to hear that "the retirement funds of California govt employees are driving up the price of crude"...